Beyond the Headlines: The Government Didn’t Kill Property.
It Changed the Rules of the Game
Why I believe the 2026 Budget marks the end of tax-driven property investing—and the beginning of something better.
By Kathryn Rose
Founder, For The Buyer
Over the past couple of months, I’ve watched the reaction to the Federal Government’s proposed property tax reforms with great interest.
There has been no shortage of headlines predicting the end of residential property investing.
Some commentators have suggested established property is no longer worth buying. Others argue investors should simply buy new property because the tax outcomes are more favourable.
I think both views miss the bigger picture.
The Government hasn’t killed property investing.
It has changed the incentives.
And whenever governments change incentives, markets adapt.
The question isn’t whether Australians should stop investing in residential property.
The question is:
Do we need to become better investors?
I believe the answer is yes.
Property Has Never Been About Tax
For decades, Australians have been taught a remarkably simple formula for building wealth through residential property.
Buy an investment property.
Claim the tax deductions.
Wait.
Eventually (if you’re lucky), capital growth will do the heavy lifting.
The 2026 Federal Budget has challenged that thinking.
Changes to negative gearing, capital gains tax, trust taxation and superannuation have understandably caused many investors to question whether residential property remains an effective way to build wealth.
Although a reasonable question, I don’t think it is the right one.
Tax has always influenced investment returns.
It has never determined whether the underlying asset was a good investment.
A poorly located apartment purchased at an inflated price does not become a quality investment simply because it offers generous depreciation or tax deductions.
Likewise, a scarce piece of well-located land with strong long-term demand has historically created wealth under many different tax settings.
Tax should improve a good investment. It should never be the reason for making one.
Governments Change Incentives. Markets Change Behaviour.
Whenever governments introduce significant housing reforms, the public conversation tends to follow a familiar pattern.
Predictions of collapsing prices.
Warnings that investors will flee the market.
Claims that “property is over.”
Australia has experienced similar reactions before.
The temporary removal of negative gearing between 1985 and 1987.
APRA’s lending restrictions from 2017.
The uncertainty created by COVID-19 in 2020.
Each event generated widespread concern.
Each altered market behaviour.
Yet Australia’s residential property market continued to evolve because the fundamental drivers of housing demand did not disappear.
History does not guarantee the future. But it does remind us to distinguish between short-term sentiment and long-term structural change.
The Fundamentals Still Matter
Housing markets are influenced by many factors.
Demographics, population growth and household formation.
Overseas and interstate migration.
Housing supply and construction capacity.
Employment, wages and household incomes.
Credit availability and lending standards.
Interest rates and the cost of finance.
Planning systems and land release.
Infrastructure investment and accessibility.
Government policy and regulation.
Consumer confidence and market sentiment.
Tax policy is one of those influences.
It is not the only one.
Tax policy influences behaviour. It does not, on its own, determine long-term housing outcomes.
This systems view is consistent with the approach adopted by organisations such as CoreLogic (now Cotality), whose regular housing market research evaluates dwelling values by considering the interaction of interest rates, borrowing capacity, supply, demand, affordability and consumer sentiment, rather than attributing market movements to any single factor.
Residential property markets are complex adaptive systems. No single policy, tax change or economic variable determines long-term outcomes. Rather, markets reflect the interaction of many forces operating simultaneously.
Australia continues to face significant housing supply challenges.
The National Housing Supply and Affordability Council’s 2026 State of the Housing System report concludes that Australia continues to face deep structural housing supply challenges. While the National Housing Accord has set an ambitious target of delivering 1.2 million new homes by mid-2029, significant constraints—including planning complexity, infrastructure provision, construction costs, workforce shortages and productivity challenges—continue to limit the pace of new housing delivery.
At the same time, population growth, overseas migration and changing household formation continue to support underlying demand for housing.
Those structural fundamentals have not disappeared because tax settings have changed. They continue to interact with broader economic conditions, interest rates, credit availability and household confidence in shaping housing outcomes.
It is also important to recognise that these policy changes are occurring at a time when housing markets are already adjusting to higher interest rates, changing borrowing capacity and broader global economic uncertainty. Isolating the effect of any single policy is difficult because markets respond to multiple influences simultaneously.
That is why it is rarely helpful to attribute movements in the property market to one policy announcement alone.
The Real Change Is Behaviour
The late Nobel Prize-winning psychologist Daniel Kahneman observed that “Nothing in life is as important as you think it is, while you are thinking about it.” His point was not that important events don’t matter, but that people have a tendency to overweight the issue immediately in front of them. Major policy announcements often create exactly this effect. They dominate the public conversation, even though housing markets continue to be shaped by many interacting forces operating over long periods of time.
Nobel laureate and Economist Robert Shiller has argued, in his 2019 book Narrative Economics, that financial markets are influenced not only by economic fundamentals but also by the stories people tell themselves and each other. In this way, major policy announcements often create powerful narratives that shape investor behaviour well before their full economic effects are understood.
In my view, the Budget is likely to change investor behaviour more than it changes the underlying value of residential property.
Some investors will delay purchasing until there is greater certainty.
Some will redirect capital towards newly built housing.
Some may decide residential property no longer suits their objectives.
Others will become significantly more selective about the assets they buy.
That matters.
Because markets don’t simply respond to policy.
They respond to how people respond to policy.
Periods of uncertainty often reduce competition.
Reduced competition can create opportunity for disciplined investors who remain focused on long-term fundamentals rather than short-term headlines.
The End of Passive Property Investing
Perhaps the most significant consequence of the Budget is philosophical rather than financial.
For many years, Australians have often viewed residential property through a taxation lens.
How much negative gearing can I claim?
How much depreciation will I receive?
What tax refund will I get?
They are legitimate questions.
They just aren’t the most important ones.
More important questions are:
What exactly am I buying?
Why is this property likely to become more valuable?
Who will want to own this asset in twenty years?
What makes it scarce?
Can I improve it?
Can I create additional value?
I believe the future will increasingly reward investors who ask these questions first.
This Isn’t a New Philosophy
One of the more interesting aspects of the current debate is that many of the principles now being discussed as “the future” have quietly shaped my own investment philosophy for decades.
Over more than thirty years of investing, working in property and law, and working with clients, my thinking has continually evolved. Every market cycle, every transaction, every client, and every lesson has reinforced one central idea: sustainable wealth is built through the quality of the asset—not the generosity of the tax system.
When I established For The Buyer in 2019, that philosophy became the foundation of the business.
Long before the recent Budget announcements, I wasn’t interested in recommending property simply because it offered attractive tax outcomes.
I’ve always believed that tax should support a good investment—not justify a poor one.
That is why every recommendation we make begins with the quality of the underlying asset.
Is it scarce?
Does it have enduring owner-occupier appeal?
Does it offer genuine long-term value?
Will it still be desirable twenty years from now?
Does it have unrealised potential that the broader market has not yet recognised?
Does it provide opportunities to create additional value over time?
Does it give you a seat at the development table, should you ever choose to use it?
Does it offer multiple exit strategies as your circumstances or the market change?
And perhaps the most important question of all: Would I still want this property if the tax rules changed again?
Those questions have always mattered more than the size of the tax deduction. Great property investments should be driven by the quality of the asset, with tax acting as a tailwind—not the engine.
This philosophy is reflected in the values that underpin For The Buyer—integrity, independence, strategic thinking, education and genuine client advocacy. Our role has never been simply to help people buy property. It has been to help them make better property decisions.
Ironically, the Government’s recent policy changes haven’t required us to rethink that philosophy.
If anything, they have reinforced it.
Creating Wealth Rather Than Waiting for It
Another trend I believe we’ll see is a greater focus on creating value rather than simply waiting for it.
Instead of relying solely on capital growth, more investors are likely to consider strategies such as:
- renovating existing homes;
- constructing secondary dwellings;
- dual occupancies;
- subdivisions;
- small-scale development; or
- increasing rental performance through strategic improvements.
These strategies are not suitable for everyone.
Nor are they without risk.
But they reflect a broader shift away from passive investing towards active wealth creation.
This has always been central to the work we do at For The Buyer. Our focus has never simply been to help clients buy property. It has been to help them identify properties with underlying value, unrealised potential and strategic optionality — the kinds of assets where value may be created over time through better use, better planning, better management or better execution.
In that sense, the current policy environment has not changed our view of property investing. It has reinforced it.
Good investors do not merely wait for the market to make them wealthy.
They look for assets where value can be understood, unlocked and, where appropriate, actively created.
So, Should Australians Still Invest in Residential Property?
My answer is yes.
But perhaps not in the same way many have over the past decade.
The era of relying on generous tax concessions to compensate for mediocre asset selection appears to be changing.
The future is likely to favour investors who are more deliberate.
Who focus on the quality of the underlying asset.
Who understand scarcity.
Who appreciate the importance of land.
Who think strategically rather than emotionally.
Who see uncertainty not simply as risk—but as information.
Most importantly, I believe investors should remain discerning and resist the temptation to make decisions based solely on changing tax policy.
Taxation is an important consideration, but it should never become the primary reason for purchasing a property.
Every investment decision should be made in the context of the investor’s broader financial objectives, borrowing capacity, risk tolerance, investment timeframe and the quality of the asset itself.
The best property is not necessarily the one with the most favourable tax outcome.
It is the one that best aligns with your long-term wealth strategy.
Government policy will continue to evolve.
Markets always do.
Successful investors will not be those who react to every Budget announcement or legislative change.
They will be those who seek appropriate professional advice, understand the broader forces shaping the market, and make informed, evidence-based decisions rather than emotional ones.
Because governments don’t determine who becomes wealthy.
They influence the incentives.
The market ultimately rewards those who consistently make good investment decisions.
What do you think?
Do you believe the Government’s recent tax reforms will fundamentally change residential property investing, or simply change the way investors think about it?
I’d genuinely be interested to hear your thoughts in the comments. Healthy discussion helps all of us become better investors. If you would like to contribute to this discussion, head over to our Facebook page and let us know your thoughts. For The Buyer
About the Author
Kathryn Rose is a solicitor, real estate agent and the Founder of For The Buyer, an independent buyer’s agency that helps clients make strategic, evidence-based property decisions. With more than 30 years of experience in property, law and investment, she is passionate about helping Australians build long-term wealth through quality property selection rather than short-term market trends.
Thinking about your next property purchase?
If the recent Budget changes have left you wondering how they might affect your own investment strategy, take the time to seek independent advice before making your next decision.
Every investor’s circumstances are different. The right property is not simply the one with the best tax outcome—it’s the one that aligns with your long-term financial goals, risk profile and investment strategy.
If you’d like to discuss your next purchase or explore whether a property genuinely represents a quality long-term investment, we’d be pleased to help.
mobile: +61 (0)401 068 068
Facebook: fb.com/forthebuyer
References
Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). National, State and Territory Population (latest release)
National Housing Supply and Affordability Council. State of the Housing System 2026
Reserve Bank of Australia. Financial Stability Review March 2026
CoreLogic Australia (now Cotality). Home Value Index – Monthly Housing Chart Pack (2025–2026 editions) and Housing Market Update publications